In Melbourne, Australia, the local Yarra City Council has opted not to repair a frequently vandalized monument of British explorer James Cook, citing the ongoing costs—approximately AUD 15,000 each time—as impractical. The decision was made unanimously by the council, with Mayor Stephen Jolly emphasizing that their choice is economically driven rather than a cultural stance. The monument has been repeatedly defaced, particularly following Australia Day, a public holiday criticized by some as “Invasion Day,” which marks British colonization and has prompted debates over the country’s national identity.
The monument, situated in Edinburgh Gardens, was vandalized shortly after Australia Day, with damage and graffiti indicating the tension surrounding Cook’s legacy and its implications for Indigenous communities. Critics, including Victoria’s opposition leader Brad Battin, have argued that the council’s decision amounts to capitulation to vandals and a distortion of history. Jolly, however, countered that preserving a decorative piece susceptible to continual vandalism was neither practical nor fiscally responsible. He expressed that the removal of the monument would likely disappoint vandals who expected it to be repeatedly restored.
Meanwhile, a local chapter of the Captain Cook Society hopes to find a new home for the bronze plaques from the monument, suggesting a museum as a potential site. Society member Bill Lang expressed disappointment at the council’s decision, advocating for a more nuanced understanding of history that acknowledges both achievements and failures. As the council’s decision marks a significant point in the larger conversation about Australia’s colonial past, it reflects the ongoing struggle to reconcile heritage with contemporary perspectives on Indigenous rights.
Photo credit
www.nbcnews.com
