John Carter was desperate to find his missing fiancée, Katelyn Markham, who disappeared in Cincinnati in 2011. He pleaded for her return in interviews and even called her cellphone daily. Years later, after her remains were found in Indiana, Carter was indicted for her murder. However, he pled guilty to involuntary manslaughter, receiving a three-year prison sentence.
The decision to drop the murder charges was made by Butler County Prosecuting Attorney Michael Gmoser in order to ensure that Carter admitted guilt for Markham’s death. The plea agreement was seen as a way to achieve justice for the victim, despite the lesser punishment.
Investigators uncovered details that cast doubt on Carter’s alibi, including eyewitness accounts of strange occurrences at his home on the night Markham disappeared. Disturbing poems found in Carter’s journal suggested a possible motive for her death, as Markham had expressed doubts about their relationship prior to her disappearance.
The evidence against Carter was mainly circumstantial, with no forensic or eyewitness proof linking him directly to Markham’s death. Despite the lack of concrete evidence, Gmoser pursued the case and ultimately accepted the plea deal to secure a guilty plea. The motive behind the plea agreement was to ensure accountability for Markham’s death and prevent the possibility of Carter walking free if the case went to trial.
Photo credit
www.nbcnews.com
